TRIANGULATION ESSAY

Dystopian forms of media such as "Harrison Bergernon," Anthem, and Antz all show us how dangerous the world can be when we let others control our future, thoughts, and actions. But in each media, we are inspired by the protagonist's rejection of their oppressive governments and social norm. Each media manages to present us with a similar message, but in a unique way.

In each media, we can see there's a higher power that makes all the decisions. But the decisions they make don't benefit the citizens but the government itself. Everything is selfishly controlled by them without even the consideration of how it could detrimentally affect the people. They rule violently in order to ensure that their people will never think that they have a choice or should think independently. In "Harrison Bergernon," it's the Handicap Generals. In Anthem, there is the council. And in Antz, there is General Mandible. In "Harrison Bergernon," the government stifles people's talents in order to keep them all equal. Whereas the main mission of "Harrison Bergernon's" government is to make everyone equal, in Antz and Anthem the mission is to brainwash their people into believing that their very existence is for the "Brotherhood" or the "Colony".  Anthem and Antz both promote their mission through fear and propaganda, but in "Harrison Bergernon" they achieve their mission through handicaps and ignorance. "Harrison Bergernon" and Anthem's governments are unique in the way they incorporate fear. Fear of the past (Unmentionable Times) (Dark Ages). They make it sound like everything in the past was bad and wrong. They used fear of violence, as well as fines. Although all three governments used different methods to achieve their mission, their results were the same... complete control and no individualism.

We are now familiar with how the three governments work, but how do the people in the society react to it? They basically allow their governments to control them in every aspect of their lives. The ironic thing is that they all think they are happy and content, because that's what they are told and far be it for anyone to ever question what their government tells them. And even if there is the off chance that someone questions what they are told, the thoughts are soon expelled, due to guilt and fear, derived from brainwashing. The people in "Harrison Bergernon" aren't even able to think due to all their handicaps. The people in Anthem listen because they believe that they are nothing and the only way to find meaning is in working for the Brotherhood. In Antz, the ants are so focused on the good of the colony they don't have the time nor energy to consider the possibility of a new and better society. None of the three societies believe that there could ever be another way of life until 1 person in each community revolted against the oppression. Equality 7- 2521's  private thinking started to show on the outside and ended up catching the eye of Liberty 5-3000. Equality made Liberty doubt what the Brotherhood told her. Z's rebellion made the whole colony second guess their leaders. When Harrison cursed society and claimed that he was king, the people, even if it was for just a second, found hope. All three protagonists made their societies believe that freedom could after all be possible.

The government is oppressive towards their people, and the people accept it, but they occasionally have doubts about whether or not how they are living is really the best way. There is obviously a need for change in all three medias, but how? The key is someone who doesn't fit in because they are above everyone else. They are not content for others tell them they are. Just like everyone else, they have doubts, but it's not enough to dismiss it like everyone else. Harrison, Equality, and Z are the protagonists that have the potential of making a utopia possible. Harrison and Equality are big and strong, but even though Z is smaller, he and Equality are smart and knowledgeable. Harrison was also smart, but he didn't use his intelligence to revolt like Z and Equality. He used violence to get what he wanted, but the consequence to his brutality was death, unlike Z and Equality who lived. Z was able to start a new colony, while Equality escaped his society. All the protagonists refused to accept what they were told and therefore posed a threat to their governments. They were a threat because they reassured the people’s doubts, and consequently they became the spark for more doubts and a possible, much needed, revolution.

Ants, Anthem, and " Harrison Bergernon"  show us how grateful we should be that we don’t live in a world that the protagonists in all these medias had to experience. A place where everyone is controlled in every way and they accept it. Harrison, Equality, and Z inspire and show us that it only takes one person to speak out in order for things to truly change for the better.

Dystopic Novels: Post- Reading

1. Write a blog post that answers the following question: Which "Utopian" world should be more feared; one in which government's control is so oppressive that people have no choice for themselves, or one in which people are so falsely happy that they do NOT realize the oppression of their government's control? Be sure to explain your answer with specific examples.

In class we have been presented with novels that address how dangerous the world can be when we allow others view of perfection cloud our own. Medias such as Anthem, "Harrison Bergernon", Antz, and 1984 are all perfect examples of dystopic medias. Three out of these four medias showcase the dystopic theme through an oppressive government that allows no choice for their citizens. But in one novel (Harrison Bergernon) we are shown how people are falsely happy and don't even realize their government's oppression. So which "utopia" is worst?

In my opinion I think that false happiness is much worse than a government's oppression impacting the people's choice. Although the three medias I mentioned earlier have a society where the people aren't happy they at least have a window of opportunity to realize how broken their system is and potentially change it. The people in Anthem  and Antz are told that they are happy but the protagonists disagree and reassure the society's doubts. But in "Harrison Bergernon" the people are so handicapped and brainwashed that they actually believe that they are truly happy. Ultimately, in a world with false happiness there is no possibility of change. When Harrison revolted it meant nothing to the people because they were to stupid to understand what was happening or think through and process what he had done, and why he did it. If the people truly believe that there is nothing wrong with their way of life then there is nothing to fix or correct. This differs in the other novel where the people deep down know that not everything is right. This gives them the ability to find and address fault. 

Another thing that is better for the other three medias is that even though the governments brainwash the people, if they aren't happy then the governments have a problem. The people's unhappiness keeps them in check at least to some degree. In 1984 the unhappiness of the people is definitely evident as we can see when Julia tells Winston that she has had previous relationships with others. This shows the need for individual expression among the society. Something the government hates and doesn't allow. But the unhappiness at least makes everyone long for more, but when the society actually thinks that they are happy, then what else is there to want? 

Both forms of dystopic societies are bad and dangerous, but false happiness is much worse. This means that the government can do whatever they want with out consequences, but at least the unhappiness of the other societies keeps the government in check. Ultimately, when a government is oppressive there is at least a little hope of freedom and individualism. But when when there is false happiness there is no hope. And that is the most dangerous thing that any society could embrace.

 

PRE-READING FOR DYSTOPIC NOVELS

1. We have been looking at and reading short stories and novels about worlds that are seen as Utopian (to at least someone in the novel).  Write a blog post about your perfect Utopian society.

It's sometimes hard to imagine a perfect world where everything that we ever wanted in life exists. A place where we never find ourselves dissatisfied with where or who we are. A world where life is truly perfect and we can never feel pain or sadness. It's hard because the world we live in is so far away from our perfect utopia. But even though it's tough to imagine it can still sometimes be a little fun to flirt the idea that such a perfect world exists even if it is truly impossible. 

So the question is "What is my perfect utopia?".  

I think my idea of a perfect world would be a society where everyone had a small town mentality. A small town where everyone knows everyone else's name and business. But it would all be fine because when it came down to it you knew that if you ever needed anything there would a swarm of people there in a matter of seconds. You never have to wonder whether you are loved or accepted.  You all have your part and you do it for each other not because you need to, but because you want to.  The people in the town would not be exactly the same, but they would have the same morals and principles to guide themselves and each other.  You wouldn't have to have the traditional law enforcement or rules because everyone knew the right thing to do on their own. 

Now I know it may seem like I'm describing The Amish, but I promise I'm not. I believe in more of the Mayberry scene. The idea of leading a simple life and still being completely satisfied. Just having a great family value not just within your home, but with everyone. I think this would be the key to my happiness. Happiness in it's simple and beautiful form. I think I must have been born in the wrong time period. I think that maybe what I described was how life used to be. Before all the new technology and ideas. And those new things in and of themselves aren't bad, but like everything else have been perverted. I think my perfect utopia is a place where everyone could just press the pause button and be able to experience the new and great things without having the time to taint them. 

Even though our perfect world can never really come true I think that we all deserve at least a taste of our own utopia at some point in our lives.